Slow star results in Withy cup exit

09:38 14 November 2012

Action from the Withcyombe defeat to Exeter Saracens

Action from the Withcyombe defeat to Exeter Saracens


Exeter Saracens 31, Withycombe 19

Withycombe went out of the Devon Intermediate Cup, but not before they had pushed their higher league hosts all the way, writes Jamie Roach.

Not for the first time this season Withy were slow to get into the game and this was a prime factor in them conceding a brace of early tries, both of the softer nature, that saw the Exeter side into a 14-0 lead.

Eventually Withy got their act together and were son showing that they had the wherewithal to comfortably deal with all that Saracens could throw at them.

This despite the controversial sin binning of number-eight Mike Richards. Shortly after his re-introduction, Richards made his presence felt by snaffling an opportunistic try from a pick and go five metres out.

Though the scoreboard remained static, the game was a neutral’s delight: Withycombe taking the opportunity of a cup game to run the majority of their penalty and free kick decisions, as well as the venomous edge endemic to local derbies.

On his return from exile in the centre, John Parkin in particular proved to be a persistent thorn in Sarries’ side from quick taps and in broken play. If nothing else, the display showed that in addition to the pace of Mike Symons, Parkin’s ingenuity gives Withy an embarrassment of riches at scrum-half. Another quick tap was to give Withy their next score, this time Mike Richards going quickly form the scrum base and being unlucky not to be awarded a try after grounding on the line; Jamie Rose made sure by dotting down from the ensuing ruck and Withy went into the break just two points adrift at 14-12.

At half-time the Withycombe team talk was of building on their gathering momentum. For all their demonstrations of competence though, they failed to follow through with execution, starting the second half as slowly as they started the first.

Saracens scored from the first play as Withycombe backed off the two or three big runners that defined Sarries’ attacking game. They capitalised on some woeful defending shortly after to make it 31-12, with hopes of a Withycombe comeback looking lost.

Credit to Withycombe though, they never gave up. Positives included the strong Withycombe scrummage which was unfairly penalised time and again, and the debut of Jamie Roach who acquitted himself well under considerable duress.

Withycombe enjoyed a fruitful ten-minute spell in the second half, starting with a turnover from the industrious Jack Pugsley, with Mike Richards putting in a highly improbable grubber kick from the halfway line which gave the lightning quick Will House the simplest of finishes to finally break his 1st XV duck with a try!

Pugsley’s conversion meant that with 15 minutes remaining, two more tries would win it for Withy, and a fantastic break from the ensuing kickoff gave them hope, only for a pass to go astray five metres out with the try-line begging.

At the next scrum, Withycombe were again controversially penalised and the pressure was relieved; it was to be the last meaningful action in a highly entertaining game.

In all likelihood Sarries were as good as anything in Withycombe’s league; the game was there for the taking but ultimately inconsistency robbed them of an eye-catching scalp. It’s back to league action this Saturday with a Raleigh Park meeting with mid-table OPMs.


Other Sport Stories

Football goalnet. Ref shsp 7216-33-15SH. Picture: Simon Horn

Budleigh Salterton Under-15s were 3-1 winners when they entertained Whipton Youth at Greenway Lane, writes SpursTom.

Read more
20151004 Copyright onEdition 2015©
Free for editorial use image, please credit: onEdition

Withycombe RFC U12's team at The Land Rover Premiership U11's Rugby Cup, Exeter - Land Rover is a proud supporter of grassroots rugby and a partner of the Land Rover Premiership Rugby Cup for nearly a decade. Land Roverâ We Deal In Realâ campaign aims to champion grassroots rugby on the global stage during Rugby World Cup 2015. Follow @Land RoverRugby #WeDealInReal

For press contacts, contact: Michael White at Fast Track on E: or T: +44 (0)20 7593 5200

If you require a higher resolution image or you have any other onEdition photographic enquiries, please contact onEdition on 0845 900 2 900 or email
This image is copyright onEdition 2015©.
This image has been supplied by onEdition and must be credited onEdition. The author is asserting his full Moral rights in relation to the publication of this image. Rights for onward transmission of any image or file is not grant

Withycombe Under-12s started their season in style, finishing runners up in the Land Rover Cup held at Exeter Saracens last Sunday.

Read more
Exmouth Cockles are pictured in their game with Newton Abbot at the Imperial ground on Saturday. Ref exsp 2754-41-15SH. Picture: Simon Horn

Exmouth scored five tries as they eased into the last four of the Devon Cup with a 39-27 success at home to Newton Abbot.

Read more

Replay defeated Exejets 40-26 when the teams met in an Exmouth Netball League match.

Read more

When Budleigh girls travelled to West Exe last month for a cup match, they came back with a comfortable victory, writes SpursTom.

Read more
Football generic picture

Exmouth Town exited from the FA Vase last Saturday in a match that was marred by a serious injury to Andrew Thomson, writes John Dibsdall.

Read more

Exe first eleven were 3-2 winners at Plymouth Marjons and so continued their fine start to the new season.

Read more
football generic picture

Exmouth Amateurs Reserves were winners by the odd goal in five when they entertained Topsham Town Reserves.

Read more

Replay emerged as 39-26 winners when they met Assent in a contest that was played throughout at a high tempo.

Read more

University of Exeter were the visitors to Greenway lane for the Division One league match, having scored 11 goals without conceding in the two games they have played so far this season, writes SpursTom.

Read more

Local Weather



max temp: 15°C

min temp: 10°C

Most Read Sport

Great British Life

Great British Life

Useful Links

Advertise in the Paper
Submit a Story
Subscriptions Order
Photo Orders
Family notices
Google Plus
Reader Travel

Family Notices 24

Read Online

Read the Exmouth Journal e-edition E-edition

Search for a job in Exmouth

Local business directory

Exmouth's trusted business finder

Find planning applications