Win or lose cricket this summer for Budleigh and Exmouth in the Devon League

21:32 01 February 2012

The clubs initially made their proposal to the council in October

The clubs initially made their proposal to the council in October

Archant

Devon’s top ten cricket teams have voted to play straight win-or-lose cricket next season for the first time in the history of the Devon League, writes Conrad Sutcliffe.

Since the league was formed in 1972, clubs have played a format of the game that allows for a draw if the side batting second can’t win the match but avoid being bowled out.

The format was designed to replicate the sort of cricket played for more than 100 years in Devon before the advent of league cricket – and was encouraged by the England and Wales Cricket Board right up until last year.

The ECB paid leagues a cash bonus to distribute between clubs for sticking with old-fashioned ‘draw’ cricket.

The reason was to replicate in miniature the skills needs to win matches at Minor Counties level and higher, where teams have to bowl the opposition out to win matches.

A win-lose experiment was trialled in the Birmingham League Premier section last season with ECB’s blessing, and proved a success.

Devon League Premier Division clubs have been hankering to ditch ‘draw cricket’ for many years and for 2012 only they have their wish on a trial basis. In come 10-over limits per bowler, powerplays, fielding circles and net run rate to decide the winner in rain-affected games.

The Duckworth-Lewis formula had no takers. Initially, only Premier Division clubs are switching to win-lose cricket – and they will have to vote next year to retain or return to draw games.

In his preamble before discussion and voting took place, league chairman Joe Clowes said clubs would be deciding on the, ‘most significant’ change to the way games are played in the history of the league’. Significant it may have been, but there was very little support for retaining winning-draw cricket when the time came to vote.

Only Torquay and Exeter, who won’t be affected next season as they are an A Division club, expressed serious reservations about the switch. Exeter’s Bruce Coleman said without the incentive to bat for a draw when there was no chance of winning, matches could become meaningless. “If you are batting second and lose early wickets there is no point making the effort and the game could be over in 20 overs,” warned Coleman.

Torquay, who are back in the Premier this summer after an absence of two years, also spoke against the motion. Skipper Justin Yau said the best game Torquay played in on their way to winning the A Division title was a draw at Braunton. “It was a fantastic game of cricket that kept everyone gripped right to the end,”said Yau.

However, representatives from Sidmouth, Heathcoat, Exmouth and Budleigh Salterton all spoke in favour and carried the day by a 7-3 margin. Only Premier clubs voted, at the request of the management committee.

Curiously, when Topsham and Kenn teamed up to ask for shorter games in the D and E Division 2nd XI competitions, there was overwhelming opposition to them going it alone in 40 over games.

A succession of clubs – Chagford, Lewdown, Chelston, Torquay, Dartington, Seaton and Whitchurch all lobbied against.

Only five of the 60-odd clubs there voted in favour and the motion was lost. Most off the other motions passed on the night were tidying up measures dealing with registrations or the awarding of points.

Two of the more significant changes related to the points split in drawn games – still applicable outside the top flight – and restrictions on overseas players.

To qualify for two draw points a side batting second has to reach two-thirds of the target needed to win. In future the side batting first will get eight points rather than six if they keep the chasing team below the benchmark figure. League bosses also moved to close a loophole which allows players with EU passports but born outside the Union to bypass the current rules of one overseas player per club. ”Last season we had Hungarians, Poles and all sorts playing, who were nothing more than Australians or New Zealanders whose grandfathers had emigrated, and that is not healthy for cricket.” The clubs overwhelmingly agreed, voting 55-2 in favour of closing the loophole.

0 comments

Other Sport Stories

Yesterday, 19:24
Exmouth took on Weston at the Imperial Ground on Saturday. Ref exsp 3541-17-15SH. Picture: Simon Horn

Exmouth coach Jon Hill spoke the day after his team’s heart-breaking play-off extra-time defeat to Barnes.

Read more
Yesterday, 19:14
Devon and Somerset Gliding Club provide airtime for Volunteer Gliding Squadrons and this is the latest group to be looked after.

Devon and Somerset Gliding Club has been selected by the British Gliding Association to provide continuation training in the South West region as part of a nationwide grant scheme provided by Royal Air Force Charitable Trust, writes Jill Harmer.

Read more
Yesterday, 18:46
Exmouth Town took a 2-0 victory over St Blazey at Southern Road on Saturday. Ref exsp 3583-17-15SH. Picture: Simon Horn

Exmouth Town completed their South West Peninsula League (SWPL) season with a 2-2 draw at Godolphin Atlantic, writes John Dibsdall.

Read more
Yesterday, 12:29
Football generic picture

Another Exeter and District League season has come to an end and so how did local teams fare over the course of the eight month campaign?

Read more
Saturday, April 25, 2015
Exmouth took on Weston at the Imperial Ground on Saturday. Ref exsp 3556-17-15SH. Picture: Simon Horn

Exmouth suffered play-off despair as they went down to visiting Barnes 27-22 in a match that swung both ways during a compelling first 80 minutes and then extra-time.

Read more
Saturday, April 25, 2015

After the long winter wait the opening drive of a new Madeira Bowls Club season was played out on a lovely sunny day, writes Matt Marriott.

Read more
Saturday, April 25, 2015
Budleigh Salterton members out in force for the start of a new outdoor season

The Budleigh Salterton Bowls Club outdoor season is underway.

Read more
Saturday, April 25, 2015
A competitor in action at the Whindwhistle Motor Club meeting

A single venue classic car trial, organised by Windwhistle Motor Club (Chard) proved to be a huge success, writes Paul Bagnall.

Read more
Friday, April 24, 2015
Exmouth took on Weston at the Imperial Ground on Saturday. Ref exsp 3576-17-15SH. Picture: Simon Horn

The Cockles go head-to-head with Barnes tomorrow (April 25) with the winners stepping up into National Two (S). Here we take a look at the visitor’s to the Imperial Ground where kick-off is 2.30pm.

Read more
Friday, April 24, 2015
skittles generic picture

There were some good scores in the latest round of matches in the East Devon Hunt Skittles League.

Read more

Local Weather

Sunny

Sunny

max temp: 10°C

min temp: 4°C

Most Read Sport

Advertise in the Paper
Submit a Story
Subscriptions Order
Competitions
Photo Orders
Family notices
iwitness24
Google Plus
Facebook
Twitter
Family Notices 24

Digital Edition

Image
Read the Exmouth Journal e-edition today E-edition



Exmouth's trusted business finder